社会中的国家:迈向国家与社会的综合性范式李杨郭一聪译,南京:江苏人民出版社👷🏿‍♀️。

李剑💨,2014🌿👦,《转变中的“强”国家—国家能力的理论逻辑及其演进》,《国外理论动态》第6期。

曾毅,2014🧑‍🦳,《社会变迁视野下的国家能力——评乔尔-米格代尔著作中的国家-社会关系理论》,《国外理论动态》第6期。

State in Society: Towards a Comprehensive Paradigm of State and SocietyA Review of

State in Society: Studying how States and Societies Transform and Constitute one another

HOU Li-wen

Abstract: The relationship between the state and society is the basic proposition of social science, which is also a controversial topic area. On the basis of reflection and dialogue to the relation between state and society, Joel S. Migdal is aware of the "reductionism" tendency in Weber's view of State, and then he constructs a new state definition, puts forward the unique "view of State" on the basis of empirical research. Meanwhile, combining with the perspective of procedural, he constructs the path "state in society" from the perspective of methodology, makes a new dynamic, procedural and constructive interpretation of the relation between state and society, which avoids the limitations of one way understanding from the old “state-centered” and “society-centered” theory, deepens the understanding of complex social reality, and opens up a new era of study on the relationship between the state and society, which also has the vital significance in methodology.

Key words: State and Society; State Outlook; State in Society




基金项目:国家社科基金项目(项目编号:15BSH053)⬜️;2015-2016年度国家留学基金委资助项目(编号:201506740014)🫰🏼。

作者简介🦈🎦:侯利文,华东理工大学社会与公共管理学院博士研究生,主要研究方向为社会工作学、社区治理🚶‍♂️‍➡️。

[]当然,“社会中的国家”具有重要的理论效度和现实解释力,在政治学界产生了重大的影响。在笔者看来😰,“社会中的国家”引领了国家与社会研究的新动向,在宏观思维解构中具有革命性的意义🖕🏽👵,但是🦻🏻,尚不足以成为“普适”意义上的理论视角⛹🏿‍♀️,尤其是对中国的国家与社会关系的研究中尚需要更多的实践检验和中观理论层面上的分析框架的佐证,这也预示了“国家与社会”关系研究的拓展空间,也构成了笔者努力的方向。关于国家与社会关系的新的综合性分析范式的努力🗻,笔者将另撰文加以讨论。

[]这其实也是《社会中的国家》带给尊龙凯时娱乐的一个重要的研究启示,但此启示现在看来似乎并没有被学者们很好利用和发挥🧍🌳。在笔者看来🥴👩‍🎓,中观层面的分析进路是深化与推进“社会中的国家”理论范式现实关切的重要方向。